Can We Ditch That Colonoscopy?

Can We Ditch That Colonoscopy?

Kosher Fitness
By Michael Ungar

Several new outlets including NPR and AARP Bulletin, have reported that there may be an alternative to a colonoscopy in the prevention of colorectal cancer. Forty percent of adults between the ages of 45 and 75 who should be screened for the disease do not do so–many because they simply do not want to go through the process of a colonoscopy. I have blogged about this in the past; it is essential to get screened to catch the disease early. I have even blogged about my own experience with the regular testing.

The new alternative is a blood test that may prove to be a more effective form of screening since it would most likely increase the number of people willing to get tested. The new test, according to The New England Journal of Medicine, was able to detect cancer in 83% of cases. This is a similar level to those using the current methods to detect colorectal cancer. The blood test is able to indentify DNA material given off by tumors; if that material is identified, a follow-up colonoscopy can be done to make a final determination of the diagnosis.

This is great news–especially for older adults. While I am willing–and even enthusiastic–about getting my regular testing, I understand that it is not the same for everyone. I am almost 61 and in relatively good shape. A colonoscopy is a trying experience for those who are more frail. Hopefully this new blood test will be another tool in the physician’s utility belt in helping to preserve and promote good health.

In any case, be sure to communicate with your healthcare professionals about the best way for you to be screened. Early detection is your friend.

This lightly-edited blog was originally published on kosher-fitness.com on 5/21/24 by Rabbi Ungar. 

About the author

Our fitness columnist and blogger Michael Ungar is an ACE-Certified Personal Trainer and Functional Aging Specialist. As the owner and operator of At Home Senior Fitness (athomeseniorfitness.net) based in Beachwood, his clients range from their early 60s to their mid-90s. Michael got serious about fitness in his 40s and started competing in his 50s. As an ordained rabbi with a small congregation in Cleveland Heights, this blog explores topics of interest to older adults, particularly health and fitness. The Hebrew word "Kosher" means "fit." (Kosher food is literally fit to be eaten; the title of his blog pays tribute to his two careers.)

3 Comments

  1. I had a polyp with a very early stage neoplasm that was completely removed during my 1st colonoscopy at age 66…thankfully it had not progressed anywhere.. This would not have been detected otherwise…. Something like this is completely preventable… Don’t fear it.. Have a colonoscopy..

  2. Toughen up people. It’s not that bad. I have a condition requiring me to have a colonoscopy every two years since I was 33. Now I’m 50.
    It’s a piece of cake for me now.

  3. Well, there’s nothing to “toughen up” about. I had a colon resection over 15 years ago and had 12 inches of my colon removed, had the obligatory colonoscopy tests every 3 to 5 years after that…HOWEVER, at the age of 79, I am reluctant to have one due to the high risk of perforation of the colon and needing to have a colostomy bag. Certainly it is an individual choice. I did however write to my doctor and ask her if she is familiar with this test and if she can order it> A great alternative>

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like

Independence with Responsibility

We are autonomous beings. We can choose to live in a healthy way--exercising, eating healthily, getting proper rest, etc.--or we can let unhealthy habits take over our lives. Our bodies provide us a certain amount of freedom, but we have a responsibility to our bodies as well. If we do not treat them right, they will rebel and we will suffer.